THE GEORGIST NEWS

    WEB EDITION
    Volume Eight, Number Six   December 1, 2005


    Welcome to the December 1 issue of The Georgist News.

    Start thinking now about your New Year's Resolutions. Make at least one resolution that pertains to economic justice, and share it with the Georgist News. Happy holidays!

    The deadline for our January 2006 issue is December 24.

    You can always reach the Georgist News at gn@progress.org

    CONTENTS: (to return here just click the headline)

        *  THIS JUST IN - A Superb Newsletter
        1. A Report from Oregon
        2. Three Notes from the CGO
        3. Georgist History Project
        4. Hartzok Paper to Appear in Think Tank Periodical
        5. New Georgist Web Site
        6. New Georgist Email Discussion List
        7. The Henry George Birthplace
        8. Listen to Dave Wetzel
        9. Important New Email Address for Georgist Hub
      10. Tax Reform Commission Final Report
      11. Common Ground-USA Website Now Searchable
      12. A Georgist History Puzzle
      13. Essay Competition - Last Chance
      14. Additional Georgist Opportunities
      15. Tradable House Price Futures
      16. Earth Day's Founder & Dec. 22 Worldwide Events
      17. AT THE MARGIN: Quips and Quotes
      18. About The Georgist News

    * THIS JUST IN - A Superb Newsletter

    GN Comments: On November 29 I received a wonderful newsletter via email. It is the first issue of "Earth Rights Review," published by the Earth Rights Institute.

    The newsletter is newsy, beautiful, and upholds Georgist principles. Don't miss it! Contact Alanna Hartzok, co-director of the Earth Rights Institute, to request a copy. You can reach Hartzok at earthrts@pa.net


    1. A Report from Oregon

    GN Comments: In a previous issue of the Georgist News, we asked readers to ponder how we are making a Georgist point in our lives, and asked what activities are engaging your attention these days. Here is a nice response from Richard Reid in Oregon (U.S.).

      "Many in Oregon are educating people about 1) the public subsidy of growth (CityWatch, Oregon Communities for a Voice in Annexations); 2) our right as taxpayers and citizens to vote on annexations (Oregon Communities for a Voice in Annexations); 3) that property rights derive from the consent of the governed and cannot be severed from governance (1000 Friends of Oregon); 4) that taxation funds the services that make our lives safe and whole and profitable (Tax Fairness Oregon, Citizens for Oregon's Future, Oregon Center for Public Policy).

      "A very small number of us are refuting the consensus that "the government must pay" whenever an economic use of land is constrained by law, with the argument that 'the landowner must pay' whenever land values increase as a result of land-use planning, annexation or condemnation.

      "These are all indirect presentations of the Georgist perspective. I believe an attempt was made during the last session of the Oregon legislature to introduce a Georgist bill but am unaware of its fate."

    GN Comments: For additional information on Georgist activities in Oregon, contact the Forum on Geonomics at jjs@geonomics.org and at www.geonomics.org


    2. Three Notes from the CGO

    1. Yearly dues of $50 USD for voting organizations and $25 USD for individual non-voting affiliates will be due by 12/31/05. Additional funds are welcome to allow for conference scholarships! For more information, contact Sue Walton at sns@swwalton.com
    2. At its Philadelphia conference the CGO voted to develop a CGO Resource Center and Skills Exchange. This is now set up as a form database on the CGO website so we can each ask for what we need and share what we know best.
      CGO members, please check it out and fill in the form yourselves at www.progress.org/cgo/skills.html
    3. A set of photos from the 2005 CGO conference in Philadelphia are viewable at www.progress.org/cgo/conf2005/


    3. Georgist History Project

    by Ed Dodson

      I suspect I am beginning to sound like a broken record, but my research into Georgist history keeps bringing to light the need to reach out to longtime Georgists who might have in their basement or attic material that deserves to be preserved and given new life.

      The Henry George birthplace is yielding a rich body of writing and other documents going back to Henry George's own lifetime. Slowly I am setting up files and cataloguing this material as part of a broader effort to organize the birthplace library. Our goal is eventually to add a list of the books and other materials in the library to our website. Since initiating this work, I have scanned, formatted and added several hundred Georgist writings to the School of Cooperative Individualism on-line library.

      Another component of documenting - and creating a living history of - the Georgist movement is building a library of audio and video materials. One day it would be amazing if we could go to a Georgist history website and listen to inspirational talks given decades ago by some of the movement's leading thinkers. I have found numerous references to radio broadcasts and television programs in the U.S., the U.K., Australia, Canada and other countries. Unfortunately the birthplace archives do not include any of this material.

      One example is a reference, in the Henry George News report on the 1966 Henry George School conference, to the playing of a tape recording of an earlier speech made by John Z. White, a prominent Chicago Single-Taxer. The report indicates attendees were greatly inspired by listening to this recording. What might have happened to this recording? My thought is that it became part of the holdings of the St. Louis extension of the Henry George School. Which brings up this question: what happened to the Georgist material housed in the extension when it was finally closed?

      I would very much like to hear from anyone who has material they might be willing to donate for inclusion in the birthplace library.

    You can reach Ed Dodson at ejdodson@comcast.net


    4. Hartzok Paper to Appear in Think Tank Periodical

    The Canada West Foundation requested Alanna Hartzok's permission to reprint a brief version of her article, "The Alaska Permanent Fund: A Model of Resource Rents for Public Investment and Citizen Dividends," in the next issue of their magazine, Dialogues. Canada West Foundation is a major Canadian think tank, and Hartzok is a Georgist who runs the Earth Rights Institute and is president of the Council of Georgist Organizations.

    Hartzok's article can already be found at www.earthrights.net/docs/alaska.html

    For more information about the Canada West Foundation visit http://www.cwf.ca


    5. New Georgist Web Site

    GN Comments: We welcome a new Georgist web site, called "Wealth and Want."

    This new site was created by Wyn Achenbaum and is the product of years of data collection, organizing and arranging to make an adaptable yet thorough presentation of Georgist ideas. Achenbaum invites your comments and suggestions.
    Visit www.wealthandwant.com


    6. New Georgist Email Discussion List

    GN Comments: A new Georgist email discussion list has been created, called Geo-Law. List information can be found at http://lists.topica.com/lists/Geo-Law/prefs/info.html

    List manager Wyn Achenbaum says: To subscribe, send an email to Geo-Law-subscribe@topica.com This was an outgrowth of discussions at the August, 2005, CGO meeting in Philadelphia, and is a place for discussing the Public Trust Doctrine, Proposition 13, Oregon's Measure 37 and similar topics.


    7. The Henry George Birthplace

    by Ed Dodson

      A newspaper article from a Philadelphia paper dated 30 August, 1904, describes the efforts by "Single Taxers" and others to acquire the Henry George birthplace. In 1904 the building was duly purchased by the Historical Society. Up to that time the property was used as a boarding house. A Dr. Martin of Philadelphia was instrumental in having the property acquired "to be [setting it] up with the books, pamphlets and letters of Henry George" in order "to make it a fitting memorial to his labors in his chosen field of endeavor."

      The building was eventually purchased by the Henry George Foundation in 1926 and is now serving as headquarters for the Henry George School of Social Science. I have not been able to uncover any details of how the building was utilized between 1904 and 1926. For some period of time there was an active Single Tax Club in Philadelphia. Perhaps its members continued to look after the birthplace. I suspect there is a good deal more to learn about these early decades.


    8. Listen to Dave Wetzel

    GN Comments: Perhaps you occasionally feel tired of reading. As a change of pace you can give your ears some Georgist food for thought by visiting www.globalpublicmedia.com/interviews/523

    You will find an opportunity to hear Dave Wetzel, vice-chair of Transport For London and chair of The Labour Land Campaign, discussing congestion charging and land value taxes.


    9. Important New Email Address for Georgist Hub

    For many years a lot of Georgists have been accustomed to contacting Sue and Scott Walton. Sue's main email address has changed from swalton@surfbest.net to sns@swwalton.com

    This change has already taken effect. Please make a note of it. From now on use sns@swwalton.com


    10. Tax Reform Commission Final Report

    Chuck Metalitz of the Henry George School of Chicago (Illinois, U.S.) has performed the massive task of extracting the passages of Georgist interest from the recently released report of the "President's Advisory Panel on Federal Tax Reform."

    You can find Metalitz's comments and compilation of passages at http://menace.bloghorn.com/23


    11. Common Ground-USA Website Now Searchable

    The website of Common Ground-USA now offers a search function that enables one to search the pages of the CGUSA site, including the entire online collection of articles from GroundSwell, the membership periodical.

    To view the Common Ground-USA website visit www.progress.org/cg/

    GN Comments: This search function is available to any Georgist site courtesy of Ask Henry, our movement's overall search engine. For more information, contact info@askhenry.com


    12. A Georgist History Puzzle

    by Ed Dodson

    The American writer Kathleen Norris is quoted in Georgist materials, as follows:

      "Anyone who really fears a revolution in America ought to re-read Henry George's "Progress and Poverty", one of the great social documents of our time.... I have never known his premises to be shaken in the least."

    Does anyone have a source for this quote?

    Ms. Norris (1879-1966) was a renowned author with strong libertarian inclinations. In May of 1955 she visited the Henry George School in New York and announced her intention to write a novel in support of the theories of Henry George. I have thus far been unsuccessful in discovering whether this novel was ever written or published. Does anyone know the answer to this mystery? Perhaps someone has the book in their library and would be willing to write a summary/review to share with others?

    Contact: Ed Dodson at ejdodson@comcast.net


    13. Essay Competition - Last Chance

    As we noted last month, your deadline to submit a 175-word essay and possibly win $100,000 is December 5, 2005.

    For details see www.sinceslicedbread.com

    Georgist News reader, Roy Langston, has written in to say, "I agree this is an excellent opportunity to present a brief, compelling argument for LVT to a wide - possibly very wide - audience.

    "Unfortunately, as I am not a US resident, I am not eligible to submit an entry. However, I would be willing to lend my assistance as a professional copywriter to you or anyone you know who would like to submit an entry about LVT, but who might not have the skills to craft the winning entry or even to make the finals."

    You can reach Roy Langston at rlangston@sympatico.ca
    Take advantage of his offer.


    14. Additional Georgist Opportunities

    GN Comments: Bill Gentes has written in to observe that essay contests are not the only good opportunities for getting our message in front of people who need to see it. In addition to our own media, there are occasional channels opened by the large mainstream media to contributions from the public. As an example, Gentes attached this 500-word commentary that he wrote recently for National Public Radio's "This I Believe" program. Let's hope that it is picked up and broadcast:

      I'm a child of the 50's and 60's in marvelous Marin County, California, and I'm feeling depressed, cheated, and anxious about the future.

      If I'd had the foresight to buy real estate during my younger years, I would be rich and powerful now. Real estate in Marin has been going bananas for decades.

      But as the cost of housing continues to rise in California, as well as the rest of the country, I am priced out of my native territory.

      I'm living in a small apartment in the Sierra Nevada foothills. The compensation I make for my work is plummeting. And I can't help but obsess on how silly it is, under the current system, for me to work, to provide goods and services for a living.

      Here is why I am anxious. Not only Marin, not only California, not only the U.S., but the world, itself, is addicted to an outmoded, exclusionary form of ownership and control of the land and natural resources which disrupts a natural economic power balance. It is as if our economy has unconsciously fallen into a vast multi-generational pyramid scam. Our hallowed free market can never truly be free with such fundamental checks and balances so out of kilter.

      Land costs skyrocket, and cities sprawl across rich farmland, as expensive, hoarded land in the populated areas forces builders to leapfrog ever farther into the hinterlands.

      The system does not create true prosperity for all: it hemorrhages wealth from those who create it to those who have the power to appropriate it. It imposes a revolving debt that must be paid by those who are not a part of the economic power structure; for instance, me.

      And it comes at an exorbitant price: unsupportable housing costs, regressive taxation, poverty, inflation, economic and cultural polarization, recessions, and depressions.

      I believe there is a solution. Everything besides land, you can own. You devise it, you create it, you make it, you get to keep it. It's that simple. Land and resources, though, should no longer be subject to that mode of ownership. One may still hold private title to land, but he must pay for the privilege in a manner that captures the speculative value and distributes it for the benefit of all.

      As I write this, I am aware of how nutty my words sound: as out of tune with current mainstream thought as abolitionism would have sounded to denizens of the 16th century, or the concept of democracy would resonate with those living in the year 400. Clearly it will require a paradigm shift.

      Of course, I can still choose to join the fray. For me the decision is whether to remain an apartment dweller, work for a living, and make do with an ever dwindling share of the value I create as an American worker or, regretfully, buy into the pyramid scam as I try to figure out a how to survive the next recession or depression or worse.

      In the meantime, as I inhabit my non-coastal, lower-middle-class apartment, I hunger for an evolution in human consciousness and survey my chances of staying out of poverty as I enter old age. For my fellow human beings, who are suffering from even worse conditions, I have to ask, how bloody long, and at what price in human suffering?"


    15. Tradable House Price Futures

    GN Comments: Richard Biddle, director of the Henry George School of Social Science and Henry George Birthplace Museum in Philadelphia (Pennsylvania, U.S.), has sent in this newspaper clipping from the Associated Press:

      The Chicago Mercantile Exchange has committed itself to offer trading next year in U.S. home prices, creating a new vehicle to play or hedge housing prices, the Associated Press reported on November 10.

      Housing-price futures, based on the median home price in ten U.S. cities, may provide protection for mortgage companies, home builders and anyone with exposure to residential real estate, the AP said.

      The investment product is set to debut in April, based on a final go-ahead given by the Merc after months of review. The concept of real-estate futures has been discussed since the early 1990s, the AP reported.

      Investors will be able to trade contracts electronically based on median home prices in Boston, Chicago, Denver, Las Vegas, Los Angeles, Miami, New York, San Diego, San Francisco and Washington, D.C., or a composite index of the cities, the AP said.

    GN Comments: What does this mean for Georgists? Is the new tradable "instrument" a silly thing to ignore or a potentially useful tool to help make a Georgist point?


    16. Earth Day's Founder & Dec. 22 Worldwide Events

    GN Comments: We have received some notes from John McConnell, the founder of Earth Day:

      December 22, 2005 - GLOBAL MINUTE FOR PEACE DAY - CELEBRATE!

      The first observance of a global Minute for Peace was at the time of President John F. Kennedy's death. His efforts to see peace realized through the United Nations were ended in Dallas at 19:00 GMT, the very moment on the global clock when the United Nations Charter was signed eighteen years earlier. In the Minute for Peace broadcast given at the end of the mourning period (December 22, 1963), a recording of President Kennedy was broadcast globally, preceded by front-page announcements in many newspapers telling when this would occur.

      The recording was from Kennedy's speech at the United Nations, September 25, 1961:

      "Never have the nations of the world had so much to lose or so much to gain. Together we shall save our planet or together we shall perish in its flames. Save it we can - and save it we must - and then shall we earn the eternal thanks of mankind and, as peacemakers, the eternal blessing of God."

      It's amazing how many different views are expressed about the issues which separate us. Too often we reject those who differ with us. The message of Christmas was peace and good will - to all people. Everyone can agree that we need peace on Earth, and unite in support of a Minute for Peace Day that will stimulate minutes for peace every day on radio and TV worldwide. This is the way to change the global state of mind from fear to faith, from despair to hope.

      Let each individual who believes in the power of prayer, of goodwill, join with others on Minute For Peace Day - December 22 - conscious of being linked with others throughout the world on that day, as they pray for peace, talk about the way to peace, and purpose peace in their hearts and minds.

      To people of every religion it will be a means to realize the potentials of their faith, that if they agree at the same time, for the same purpose, they can ask what they will, and it will be done. On Minute for Peace Day they will ask, in love, for peaceful progress in their lives and throughout the world. To humanists this will be a time to ponder peace, to celebrate peace with a new awareness of our common humanity.


      For a fact-filled history of the Minute for Peace and details on the true Earth Day, visit www.earthsite.org


      "Peace is when frogs sleep on water lilies."
      - Perry Fan, Chinese kindergartner

      "Peace is when flowers say hello to the sun."
      - Debbie Oppenheim, Swedish kindergartner

      "All people can live together in peace as a family. We here at the United Nations School feel we are a family.
      - Ahmed El Bouri, Libyan boy

      "Peace starts with yourself, inside yourself. If you are happy, then with your friends you will be happy and will not fight."
      - Alexandra Pollyea, American girl


    17. AT THE MARGIN: Quips and Quotes

    Small opportunities are often the beginning of great enterprises.
    - Demosthenes

    I think I began learning long ago that those who are happiest are those who do the most for others.
    - Booker T. Washington

    Disarm, disarm. The sword of murder is not the balance of justice. Blood does not wipe out dishonor, nor violence indicate possession.
    - Julia Ward Howe


    18. About The Georgist News

    The Georgist News, a project of the Robert Schalkenbach Foundation, is an (plain text) email newsletter. It is brought to you free of charge. Its purpose is to keep you updated on the latest news, world events, projects, and initiatives of relevance to people who, like Henry George, seek a world free from special privilege and free from the causes of poverty.

    The Georgist News on the WWW - http://www.georgist.com/


    Contributing to this issue:
    Wyn Achenbaum, Richard Biddle, Ed Dodson, Bill Gentes, John McConnell, Chuck Metalitz, Richard Reid, Sue Walton
    Copy Editor: Enzo Piccone
    Proofreader: Caspar Davis
    Archivist: Stewart Goldwater
    Owner: The Robert Schalkenbach Foundation
    Founder: Adam Monroe
    Publisher: Hanno T. Beck


    The Georgist News Volume Eight, Number Six December 1, 2005